Some initial thoughts for the new Season of the Doom Patrol TV Series. Assume spoilers.
The character of Dorothy Spinner was introduced into the Doom Patrol comic before the beginning of the Grant Morrison and Richard Case run, though they brought her into the “team” as a regular. While they had some ideas, I don’t know if they, or any of the later writers, ever knew quite what to do with her. She would have important roles in the plots of stories, often struggling with the emotional and biological issues of being an adolescent, but as a character she never progressed the way the others did. Sometime she seemed to regress, becoming ever more a winey and tearful child.
In adding her to the Doom Patrol TV series, Jeremy Carver and company have made the wise decision to take the core idea of Dorothy and then rebuild her from the ground up, much as they did with as Larry and Rita (Cliff and Jane are more adaptions of the Morrison/Case versions of the characters than rebuilds). It’s a promising start, though there is still the issue of how much complexity they can give a child this young (as they have now made her) in such extreme circumstances. Starting her off with the growing threat of the Candlemaker — which was part of the culminating arc of the Morrison/Case run — also seems like a good call.
What I didn’t think worked, or was necessary, was her flashback. It was too contrived and excessive. I didn’t care for any of the flashbacks in this episode. Do these people really need even more painful revelations about their lives? I’d rather see them move forward, rather that be tortured by more and more past traumas. That’s why I find Rita the most interesting character. She’s still got a lot of problems, but she at least has something she wants to work towards. It’s just the wisdom of her goal of becoming a superhero in this show’s version of the DC Universe that remains to be seen.
Young Justice Season Two was an unrestrained celebration of the fantastical, melodramatic, ridiculous complexity of the superhero genre. It called up over eight decades of DC comic book lore, reaching without hesitation to characters and premises from the 1930’s through the 2000’s. It brought in entirely new characters and ideas while rebuilding previously well-established ones. Of the these, the most changed was the whole idea of the “Team”, reshaped from the classic idea of a group of former kid sidekicks — the “Teen Titans” — into something quire different: a covert ops squad doing what the public “Justice League” could not get away with. All of this was bound together with ideas, visual designs, and cosmic concept drawn from the bottomless well of Jack Kirby’s imagination.
This brew of the classic, the contemporary, and the remixed was the main thing that drew me to the series —and to write these posts. There was always the sense of the familiar, but accompanied by the intrigue of never knowing exactly how things would go.
That all began in Season One, but Season Two ramped everything up. These episodes went even further utilizing the story arc style of the very popular hero team comics of the 70’s and80’s: The New Teen Titans, Legion of Super Heroes, and The X-Men. Those books had very large casts and told long-form stories with multiple sub-plots that could run for years. A given issue might feature a situation with a few heroes, advance that plot a little, them jump to another location and another plot. Characters would have their own goals and emotional conflicts, and often their personal issues would clash with the larger, more superhero action focused plots. This approach added a richness and complexity to superhero storytelling, making then more like soap opera serials than that disposable action-adventure romps. Young Justice, especially in Season Two, shares in both the strengths and weakness of that storytelling form.
Sometimes there are just too many characters and too many plot lines going on at once. I enjoyed the show’s interpretation of Beast Boy, but after one story arc, he barely appeared. The modern version of Wonder Girl was good to have around, but we never had a chance to learn anything about her. Young Justice’s version of Bumblebee was on stage for more episodes, even playing an important part of the plot — but who is she, as a character? The Red Arrow and Cheshire relationship was introduced, drove the secondary plot of a few episodes, and then was gone. Impulse was a nice addition, but having him around meant other characters were pushed aside. Blue Beetle got a solid arc, and one that was unified with the larger plot, but then the attempts to connect Jamie with the history of the previous two Blue Beetles ended up feeling rushed. The strongest character story, and one that did require all 20 episodes to unfold, belonged to M’gann. She started out strong, had to face the consequences of her actions, and came out stronger and more mature than ever.
For all that, Young Justice continued its policy of having things happen. Arcs did get resolved, and stories did progress — for the most part. The discovery of the meta-gene, the reason why so many Earth people devolve super (or “meta”) powers was introduced, then largely forgotten. It was, after all, a story element from a completely different comic book series that had been grafted on to the story of the Reach. So it didn’t really have a place in what followed. And what about their plan to enslave humanity through a Reach branded soft drink?
For me frustration with the big picture plot, the structure of the season as a complete story, came from two sources. First was the ever elusive goals of the Light, and the number of times the heroes’ successes were undercut by a last minute revelation that it was all part of the Light’s enigmatic master plan. It was hard to feel like anything was progressing with so many secret schemes that we didn’t understand going on. What were the stakes when it was all so hidden? Second, there was the ever present suggestion that, somehow, Jack Kirby’s Fourth World mythology was involved, but in some foggy and out-of-focus way. We’d seen the Forever People, “Boom Tubes” were used freely, and even things such a “Father Box” showed up. These elements weren’t presented as puzzle pieces that, once brought together, would “explain” what was going on. There were just part of the torrent of comic book lore that the show unleashed on us. It’s still unclear to me how much, if anything, the characters already know about Darkseid and the rest. The classic Paul Levitz and Keith Giffen “Great Darkness Saga” in Legion of Superheroes #290-294 is an example of how you can build an ominous and escalating mystery out of Kirby lore.
In the end, Young Justice is an admirably ambitious show that only occasionally gets in over its head. It is something quite different from the sequence of shows that began with Batman: the Animated Series and culminated in Justice League Unlimited. The Bruce Timm/Paul Dini “DC Animated Universe” was a reinvention/reinterpretation/reinvigoration of DC superhero properties. Young Justice assumes an understanding, or at least a willingness to accept, a pre-existing, pre-established world full of comic book mythology. It takes that assumed familiarity and spins it insometimes quite surprising ways. It does not deconstruct, the way that Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons did in Watchmen, but works with the superhero genre form. Too often when a superhero comic tries to be “serious” it goes overboard into the violent or psychologically dark. That trend continues today with truly awful and poisonous series such as Heroes in Crisis. I’m a fan of when DC comics play with their history, with having fun with the inherent absurdities of costumed superheroes — the 2008-2011 Batman: The Brave and the Bold Animated series for instance. Young Justice shows that you can go deeper into theme, plot, and character without falling into the clichés of “grim and gritty.”